Does the FBI have the right to use Carnivore? :: Argumentative Persuasive Essays

Does the FBI have the right to use Carnivore?Carnivore is an unnecessary system that should be replaced by one that infringes less on the privacy of Internet users, such as one that records the data of certain subscribers and sends only that tuition to the FBI. The methods used for intercepting communications, from simple wiretapping to the NSAs ECHELON satellite surveillance system, have been designed as a gist of intercepting information concerning criminal and terrorist plans and using that information to apprehend suspects before they cause any harm. Carnivore, the FBIs email wiretapping system, is used to scan emails on a detail ISP that is believed to be hosting a suspected criminal. Carnivore was designed to scan packets of information passing through a router in search of suspicious activity. It looks for keywords and refers in the headers of emails and separate data that may lead to the prevention of crimes or apprehension of suspects. It is believed that Carnivo re was derived from commercial online detection softw ar known as Etherpeek. Tyson In February 1997, the system known as Omnivore was proposed to run on Solaris X86 computers. In June 1999, it was replaced by the Carnivore system, which runs on Windows NT-based computers. Konrad Carnivore is part of a system known as the DragonWare Suite. This system contains three parts Carnivore, the system that captures information Packeteer, which is believed to be used as a packet reassembler and Coolminer, an application that is thought to be capable of analyzing the data collected. Tyson It was recommended that Carnivores name be changed because its current name caused people to infer that it would aggressively invade their privacy. Because of its job as a digital collection system, it was recently renamed DCS1000. Luening It has also been said that the FBI has merely dressed its online beast in sheeps clothing Luening.When a suspected criminal is detected, a court order for investig ation must be issued, and then a Carnivore elevator car is set up at the suspects ISP. It then scans all incoming and outgoing data for every user on that ISP. It is claimed that only the headers of emails are scanned for information and that the contents are left alone, but there are questions as to whether or non this is true and, if it is not, whether citizens can trust the government not to read personal email while searching for their suspect.